February 2001

Peggy Seeger - Love Will Linger On
Appleseed APR-1039
Released: 2000

by David J. Cantor
davidc@soundstage.com

Musical Performance ***1/2
Recording Quality ****
Overall Enjoyment ***1/2

[Reviewed on CD]Peggy Seeger's Love Will Linger On is a pretty collection of love songs. Her gentle singing and piano playing are augmented by autoharp, guitar, bass, dulcimer, and other instruments, many of them played by her three children: Neil, Calum, and Kitty MacColl. Their father was Seeger’s life partner, Ewan MacColl, the English songwriter who died in 1989, the author of "The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face."

Leading off the disc with "The First Time Ever …" is a risky move. Most listeners are so familiar with Roberta Flack’s memorable, dramatic version that Seeger’s extremely low-key rendition may sound as if she doesn’t get it -- a strange notion, considering that Seeger’s is the "face" that inspired the song.

Seeger’s own "Primrose Hill," with its softly rendered, catchy melody is one of my favorites. I love its tightly structured refrain: "Come and walk in Richmond Park/Come and walk in town/Come sit on Primrose Hill/And watch the sun go down." The refrain reinforces the song’s linking of love with images from nature.

Seeger wrote "Autumn Wedding" for her brother Mike Seeger (they are half-sister and half-brother, respectively, of Pete Seeger). Playing on autumn's different meanings -- as a season of life as well as a season of the year -- the fourth verse goes, "A full life has taught him the price of tomorrow/A full life has taught her to lead as she follows/Both of them seasoned yet supple and bending/Love is preparing an autumn wedding."

The CD contains six original songs, four by other songwriters, and three traditional ballads. Of the traditional ones, I particularly enjoy "Fiddling Soldier." Many variations exist on this tale of a lady who, in this one, has "the raven black hair" and encounters "a soldier and a brave volunteer" who "took out his fiddle and tuned up one string/And he played the water gliding while the nightingale sing." The singer beseeches the soldier to "play one tune more/For I’d rather hear your fiddle and the touch of one string/Than to see the water gliding, hear the nightingale sing" and pleads with him: "O ho, said the lady, will you marry me?/O no, cried the soldier, that never can be/I’ve a wife in old Ireland and children I’ve three/One wife is a-plenty, too many for me."

This is Peggy Seeger’s 19th solo album, and she has performed on more than 100 with other artists. She has published songbooks as well. Her website, www.pegseeger.com, provides additional information about her long and enduring career as a folksinger, writer and activist. This CD is well worth a listen, especially by people who like their folk music quiet, slow and subtle.


GO BACK TO: